Is Chinese Spanking Porn Consensual?

WARNING! VIEWER DISCRETION ADVISED: Pictures of severely bruised and bleeding buttocks ahead. Some readers may find these images offensive or traumatizing. Please do not proceed if you feel this is not something you wish to see. I do not currently have the technical option of letting viewers hide the images.

Spanking porn videos produced in countries that do not subscribe to Western Human Rights appear consistently more brutal. So much so that the issue of human trafficking has been brought up in the comment section of at least one porn video. Porn comment sections are generally places of depravity. So if a human rights discussion appears in one? You know it's bad!

Many Chinese and Russian spanking sites (including Han-Duty, Spank-China, Russian Spanking, and Russian Discipline) have been recently taken offline, most likely due to the illegality of porn production within those countries. However, you can easily locate most of their videos scattered across platforms such as XVideo or Spankbang. They are some of the most severe spanking porn punishments on the web.

But does consistent severity equal lack of consent? To compare, American and British spanking sites such as Real and AAA, feature a mix of light, moderate, and severe spankings. This is a clear indication that boundaries were communicated with the model beforehand. After all, every model has different pain limits. However, with Chinese, Russian, and former Soviet bloc productions, the spankings are almost always brutal. For every single model.

One particular XVideo post titled “8885662_hd” drew quite the fire in the comment sections. The video, which features a cover photo of a Chinese woman’s bleeding buttocks, is about ten minutes long. It starts with the female’s buttocks already heavily bruised. She proceeds to endure another six minutes of flagellation until she is bleeding and hyperventilating from pain. The remaining four minutes consists of the male dominant taking photos and massaging her buttocks with what appears to be healing cream.

Commenters from all over the world, including USA, UK, Korea, Brazil, and Central America vehemently criticized the video. While most of these comments were downvoted from horny porn viewers, it was not a good look for spanking kinksters as a whole. Comments below all from the same video, alternating black and white background used for contrast.

Translation from Portuguese:

First Comment: Whoever did this has a small penis and don't know how to use it. What a ridiculous thing to do.

Second: There are women who like this.

While the critics showed concern for the submissive, the supporters mostly responded with dismissive cursing, giving the impression that people who enjoy severe spanking are callous, depraved and psychopathic.

At a time where extreme, polarized politics is the norm, such a comment section can potentially be weaponized by rigid moralists to ban BDSM porn. As spanking fans, we need to be better ambassadors of our kink, lest one day we be persecuted for it. There are people out there who see us as evil, no matter how we reason. Don’t move people uninvolved to their side.

But I digress. Is that Chinese spanking video consensual? There’s no way to know for sure. Porn production is illegal in China. As a result, their models aren’t registered and everything is done under the shadows. One Korean commenter even suggested the following:

Human trafficking is indeed a widespread problem in China. However, the good-intentioned Korean samaritan has no proof that this particular video was a human trafficking incident. Severity is not proof of human-trafficking, lack of consent, or even exploitation.

Of all the cultures in the world, China has the richest spanking history. In pre-modern Europe, judicial corporal punishment was given in the form of horse whipping the upper back. For thousands of years in China, the standard was wood on buttocks.

Furthermore, China does not subscribe to Western human rights or children’s rights. Beating children there is completely normal. There’s no CPS. Abuse there might as well be water to a fish.

Point is, if beatings are normal in a country, the beatings will be more severe. And one of the most common ways people develop a spanking fetish is when they were physically punished growing up. And the more severe the beating was, the more they can take.

Hell, listen to interviews of spanking models done by Real or Clara Fonda. The American models who can take the hardest punishments are often those spanked harder growing up. Although there are exceptions, there’s a direct correlation. So in the case of Chinese spanking porn always being severe, here’s the recap:

• Doesn’t abide by western human rights, so the population is more desensitized to brutality

• Rich history in judicial spanking, creating widespread fascinations and curiosity

• Physical punishment is a pervading cultural norm

• When beatings are normal, they are more severe

• Those who grew up beaten are more likely to develop a spanking kink

While the words of these critics are possible and well-intentioned, there did not present evidence, only intuitive outrage.

If only Chinese products were built like Chinese butts!

In America, Rachel Adams is a spanking model who regularly enjoys being spanked to the point of screaming and hyperventilation. Veronica Ricci, from the production Girls Spank Girls, spanked a model named Linny Lace well past the point of blood. Lace’s buttocks were in far worse shape than the Chinese spankee in “8885662_hd.”

Furthermore, the Chinese spankee in “8885662_hd” had a jade ring on. While this doesn’t entirely exclude the possibility of human trafficking, the presence of expensive jewelry as well as the TV being turned up for the neighbors not to hear are positive signs.

Of course, you never know. Multiple things can be true at once.

1. There are very reasonable explanations on why Chinese spanking porn can be both severely cruel and consensual.

2. But many videos could be non-consensual regardless. Such is the reality of porn produced in a country where porn is illegal.

3. Human trafficking is a big problem in China. And whenever adult services are banned, the threat of human trafficking rises.

And…that’s why Rose Spanking is so great! You can enjoy your spanking fantasies and know with 100% peace of mind that no person was harmed or exploited during production. 😀